| Clare County Library | Songs of Clare |
| Clare County Library | Songs of Clare |
|
Caroline of Edinburgh Town (Laws P27; Roud 398) Knockbrack, Miltown Malbay Recorded in singer's home, September 1977 |
||
Now gentlemen and maidens, come listen
to my rhyme, Young Henry being a highlander, sure, courting her
he came. They being no longer in London Town, scarcely one half
year, Oppressed with grief, without relief, this fair one
had to go It was on a stone she wrote a note saying, “Alas,
I am no more.”
|
||
| "In
spite of the enormous popularity enjoyed by this song among traditional
singers, it has come in for a great deal of criticism from collectors
and scholars. Malcolm J Laws described such pieces as 'cheap, vulgar and
journalistic' and, in a somewhat patronising note to the Dorset version,
Frank Purslow compared it to the melodramas 'which tatty little theatrical
troupes performed in makeshift theatres at the village fairs'. He suggested
that it was so common that 'few collectors bothered with it'. Gavin Greig
treated it more kindly in stating, 'This is a favourite ballad with the
folk-singer', and had the insight to admit that 'the tragic element is
managed with very considerable skill'. Ref: ‘American Balladry From British Broadsides’, G Malcolm Laws Jnr., pub. American Folklore Society, 1957; ‘Greig-Duncan Folk Song Collection’, Vol. 6, eds. Shuldham-Shaw/Lyle/Petrie, pub. Mercat Press, 1995. Other recordings: Belle Stewart, ‘The Stewarts of Blair’, Topic 12T 138 / Ossian OSS CD 96." The above commentary, lyrics and recording are taken from ‘Around the Hills of Clare: Songs and Recitations from the Jim Carroll and Pat Mackenzie Collection’ (2004) Musical Traditions Records MTCD331-2/Góilín Records 005-6. |
||
<< Songs of Clare |
||